The answer is: Milk

Judges 4:19

In the thrilling narrative of Judges, the story of Jael and Sisera stands out like a dramatic plot twist in a hero saga. Sisera, the general of Hatsor's army, finds himself beleaguered after his defeat by the Israelite forces led by Deborah and Barak. Seeking refuge, he stumbles upon Jael, who just so happens to be within her tent—an interesting detail considering that Jael's hospitality would lead to an unexpected turn of events.

Now, what makes milk such an intriguing choice for Sisera’s drink? During that time, milk was often considered a nourishing and comforting beverage, especially in the nomadic cultures of the Near East. Offering milk symbolizes a gesture of care, perhaps to lull Sisera into a false sense of security. Fun fact: the word “curds” appears in the original Hebrew and indicates that her offering may have been more than just plain milk—possibly, it includes cream too. It evokes an image of an ancient Mediterranean feast.

Interestingly, Jael's actions echo the recurring theme of the underestimated woman in biblical accounts. She disarmed the powerful only to be the true deliverer in a prevailing situation unnoticed by many. This twist in the tale reminds us of the various roles women have historically played in literature and scripture, often wielding great influence behind the scenes.