Your Bible trivia questions answered by Phil Logos...

Was Jesus born in 0 AD?

If you’ve ever blown out candles on your birthday cake and wondered, “How exactly do we know when Jesus was born?” you’re not alone. After all, Jesus’ birth is the starting point for the calendar most of the world uses today, right? Well, not exactly. It turns out the year 0 AD (which itself doesn’t exist in the Gregorian calendar—more on that later) wasn’t the magical starting line for Jesus’ earthly life. Instead, the calculation of his birth date has a surprising backstory filled with human error, historical sleuthing, and a few celestial clues.

Let’s dive into this fascinating puzzle and uncover why Jesus was most likely born several years before the calendar says he was.

A Monk with a Mission: The Origin of AD Dating

The AD (Anno Domini, or “Year of our Lord”) system we use today owes its existence to a monk named Dionysius Exiguus, working in the 6th century. Dionysius was tasked with figuring out a new way to date Easter each year. (Fun fact: Early Christians didn’t agree on when Easter should be celebrated, and it was a bit of a calendar nightmare!)

In doing so, Dionysius decided to create a timeline that began with what he believed to be the year of Jesus’ birth. He counted backward from the reign of Emperor Tiberius and worked out what he thought was Jesus’ birth year. However, Dionysius didn’t have access to all the historical records we have today, and he made some critical errors.

The Reign of Herod: A Historical Clue

The Gospel of Matthew gives us an important historical anchor for Jesus’ birth: King Herod the Great. According to Matthew 2, Jesus was born during Herod’s reign, and Herod ordered the infamous massacre of male infants in Bethlehem in a bid to eliminate the prophesied “King of the Jews.”

Here’s the catch: Herod died in 4 BC, and historians are confident about this date because it’s corroborated by multiple ancient sources, including the Jewish historian Josephus. If Herod died in 4 BC, Jesus must have been born earlier—likely sometime between 6 and 4 BC. Dionysius, however, didn’t account for this. His miscalculation meant Jesus’ birth was pegged to a later year than it actually occurred.

What About the Census?

Luke’s Gospel mentions another historical marker: a Roman census that brought Joseph and Mary to Bethlehem (Luke 2:1-5). This census took place during the rule of Quirinius, the governor of Syria. However, historical records indicate Quirinius’ governorship began in 6 AD—seemingly too late for Jesus’ birth to coincide with Herod’s reign.

This apparent conflict has puzzled scholars for centuries. Some suggest Luke’s account references an earlier census or that there was a prolonged period of unrest in the region that muddied the timeline. While the details are debated, the census clue still points to a birth date before Dionysius’ calculation.

Starry Skies and the Star of Bethlehem

One of the most fascinating pieces of the puzzle comes from astronomy. The Gospel of Matthew describes a mysterious “star” that led the Magi to Jesus. Over the centuries, astronomers have speculated about what this celestial event could have been—a supernova, a comet, or a rare planetary conjunction.

A popular theory is the conjunction of Jupiter and Saturn, which occurred in 7 BC. During this event, the two planets appeared so close together that they would have shone brightly in the night sky. This timing aligns well with the other historical clues, suggesting Jesus’ birth may have been as early as 7 or 6 BC.

Why No “Year 0”?

If you’ve been wondering why the term “0 AD” feels strange, it’s because there isn’t a Year 0 in the calendar we use today. The Gregorian calendar, based on Dionysius’ AD/BC system, goes straight from 1 BC to 1 AD. (Imagine celebrating your birthday without a first year of life!) This quirk adds another layer of confusion to dating Jesus’ birth because it throws off our modern sense of time.

The Political Climate: A World in Turmoil

Another piece of the puzzle is the broader historical and political climate. The Roman Empire, under Augustus, was undergoing significant changes around the time of Jesus’ birth. Augustus declared the Pax Romana, a period of relative peace, in 27 BC, and this peaceful environment might explain why Joseph and Mary were able to travel to Bethlehem for the census.

At the same time, Herod’s paranoia was at its peak in the years leading up to his death in 4 BC. He was known for eliminating perceived threats to his rule—including members of his own family. This historical context fits well with the narrative of Jesus’ early life, suggesting he was born while Herod’s reign and fear of rebellion were still in full swing.

Why Does It Matter?

You might wonder, “Does the exact year of Jesus’ birth really matter?” For most Christians, the spiritual significance of Jesus’ birth transcends the precise date. However, understanding the historical context can deepen our appreciation for the Bible’s reliability and its connection to real-world events.

For example, the alignment of the Gospels with historical figures like Herod and Augustus reminds us that the story of Jesus isn’t just a legend—it’s deeply rooted in history. At the same time, the miscalculation of Jesus’ birth year shows the limits of human understanding, even when dealing with something as monumental as the timeline of the Saviour’s life.

A Fun Twist: Would Jesus Have Known?

Here’s a lighthearted question to ponder: If Jesus knew all things, would he have chuckled at the idea that we got his birth year wrong? While we can’t know for sure, it’s a reminder of the humility and humanity of Jesus’ life. He entered a world bound by human limitations and errors, even when it came to understanding his own arrival.

Reflecting on Time and Eternity

The question of when Jesus was born invites us to reflect on something bigger: the nature of time itself. The Bible often speaks of time in two dimensions—chronos (chronological time) and kairos (God’s appointed time). While historians strive to pinpoint Jesus’ birth year in chronos, the deeper significance lies in kairos: the truth that Jesus came at exactly the right time to fulfill God’s plan of salvation (Galatians 4:4).

Wrapping It Up: Jesus, History, and Us

So, when was Jesus really born? The best guess is somewhere between 7 and 4 BC, thanks to clues from history, astronomy, and the Bible. While Dionysius’ calendar system gave us the AD/BC framework we still use today, it turns out he was off by a few years.

But here’s the bigger picture: No matter the exact year, Jesus’ birth changed the world. His arrival marked the dawn of a new era—not just on a calendar but in the hearts of billions. And that, more than the precise date, is what truly matters.

Trivia for the Road

1. Did You Know? The Eastern Orthodox Church celebrates Christmas on January 7 because they follow the Julian calendar, which lags behind the Gregorian calendar by 13 days.
2. Another Fun Fact: The term “Anno Domini” only became widely used in Western Europe during the 8th century, thanks to a monk named Bede.
3. Astronomy Buffs: Johannes Kepler, the famous astronomer, was one of the first to suggest that the Star of Bethlehem might have been a planetary conjunction.

So next time you look at a calendar, think of Dionysius, Herod, and those shining planets—and marvel at how history, science, and faith all come together to tell the greatest story ever told.