The answer is: In a cave

1 Samuel 24:3-4

In the context of David's story in 1 Samuel, the cave where he cut off a corner of Saul's cloak is often thought to be the En Gedi region, known for its beautiful cliffs and caves. This geographical setting adds a dramatic touch to what would become a pivotal moment in Israelites' history. Picture this: David is hiding out in this remote location, a simple shepherd boy, with only his wits and stealth to keep him safe from the seasoned King Saul. When David sneaks up to Saul, who’s busy in a vulnerable moment—relieving himself—it’s almost cinematic!

The act of cutting the cloak speaks volumes. In biblical culture, a cloak is more than mere cloth; it symbolizes honor and authority. By shortening Saul's garment, David wasn't just claiming a piece of his dignity but sending a testament to the deeper truth at play: he respected Saul as God's anointed king despite their rivalry. David’s actions echoed the larger narrative of mercy and divine timing—poor Saul, who is losing his grip on leadership, while David progressively steps into God's plan for him, albeit timidly at first.

Interestingly, some scholars have pointed out the spiritual symbolism behind this act. Cutting the cloak also positions David as the future king, hinting at a transition of power while also underscoring mercy as he refrains from harming Saul directly. This subplot invites readers to consider justice and forgiveness, setting the stage for more intriguing developments in the journey of Israel's most beloved ruler.